Home News news Planning Inquiry Summary Day 2

Planning Inquiry Summary Day 2

The second day of the Inquiry started with a few procedural matters.  The Inspector advised that he had completed a partial site visit on the previous evening.  He also advised that it had been noted that a member of the public had used their Meta Glasses to capture images of the first day that had been shared around social media. He advised this should not have been done without prior notification, as he had asked during the morning if any press or filming/recording would happen, and requested they not be used during the Inquiry.  The individual commented that she was not wearing them today.

The main theme of Day 2 was the discussion of Landscape and Character, including discussion of the settlement gap.

The Vale of White Horse introduced their expert witness, Mr Duffy, who presented a summary of his expert submitted papers summarising in his view the “High” weight of importance of the impacts on the Landscape and Settlement Gap.  There were several references through the day referring to a recent Appeal in Kingston Bagpuize as the appeal Granted permission. The expert was also involved in the early part of this case and highlighted the differences in that there was no golf course involved, and that Southmoor and Kingston Bagpuize were already joined settlements and various other fact pattern differences.

A discussion was held about there being a difference to the Shrivenham Plans submitted but the planning inquiry documents having more “illustrative plans” of tree planting but the witness questioned the delivery and affordability of such a scheme.  Also pointing out that the future residents of any “market” properties in the proposed new site would have to pay for a service charge to maintain this large area of 22 Hectares to be maintained.  That could be a significant financial cost to any future residents if approved.

The next segment discussed trees, with a discussion on the magnitude of the change and how long the mitigation of the tree planting would take with the views expressed ranging from 15 to 25 years.  The witness also explained that there was a difference to consider on this topic of the physical (distance) separation and the Visual (Perception) of separation – the latter taking in the impact from the public footpaths and faringdon road.

It was explained that the current perceived boundary of the built up area/urban partof Shrivenham was Pennyhooks Lane, acting as a natural boundary.  Development would lead to the perceived urbanisation beyond pennyhooks lane and lead to a significant change of character.

During these discussions there were many references made to the Shrivenham Neighbourhood plan.

Witness Cross Examination:

The session got very technical(!). Arguments focused on the view that the Golf Course did not in the appellants view represent a key part of the settlement gap, but with the trees, the Tuckmill Brook and planting that this would be the main gap.

A significant amount of time was then spent on various sections of the Shrivenham Neighbourhood Plan resulting in Bloor presenting that based on the plan the “only” areas in the Parish that could possibly be built on were the Golf course and the already allocated area at Cross Trees – the other areas appearing to be protected by the panoramic views of the Downs etc and other areas.  This was later contested.

The cross examination then focused on where the perceived built up boundary of Shrivenham lies, with the appellent arguing this is beyond the “island” of Northford Close, and includes part of the Defence Academy including Lake Road etc.

These arguments were based on trying to argue about the impact on the size of the settlement gap and so reducing the impact of the proposal.

Re-examination of witness from Vale:

The Vale Barrister was then allowed a re-examination to clarify some areas.  This focused on re-iterating the boundary was perceived as Pennyhooks Lane.  The witness also explained that in his view the landscape assessment and the focus on the separation was about the loss of the land separating not the quality/nature of the land. He also pointed out that the Shrivenham Neighbourhood Plan had been prepared professionally with proper advisors advising on the landscape assessment, not “locals” and that it stood as equal weight to the vale Plan.   He went on to counter the appellants view stating that in the neighbourhood plan the other sites were note wholly excluded due to the panoramic views in his view and re-iterated that the only area specifically called out where development should not take place was the Golf Club.

Cllr Howell was unable to attend the final 90 minutes, where the Appellant brought their Witness to present on the same topic, and they will be cross examined at the start of day 3.

A new timetable is available on the Vale planning site:

Planning: P25/V2394/O – Online Register  Click on Appeals, then Documents to find latest link to agenda.  There are many appeal documents stored on this site.(Scroll down to the bottom section called “Inquiry Documents”)

Published
October 23, 2026
Last Updated
October 28, 2026
Published in