Home News news Planning Inquiry Summary Day 3

Planning Inquiry Summary Day 3

The third day started at 9:30am with the Vale cross examination of the Appellant (Bloor) witness, Mr Gardner,  relating to Landscape and visual impact.  The discussion focused on a few areas of disagreement:

  • Susceptibility of the site to Change.  This discussion was about the site characteristics and the change impact.  The Appellant position was it was Low, whilst the Vale argue it as Medium.The Shrivenham Neighbourhood Plan (SNP) was referenced extensively again in the discussion.
  • The second area focused on the Magnitude of Change.  Both parties agreed the impact was High in Year 1.  The Appellant model included reliance on a 25 year model for assessing the mitigation of replacement planting.  The Vale argued it is industry standard to use 15, and that is what should be used.It was again pointed out that in the actual outline application there are no details of planting plans for mitigation and pointed out to the inspector that as it is “outline only” the plans on layout could be comletely changed but within the same footprint of the development site.  As Landscape planting is for a later Reserved Matters approval.  The Vale team raised the concern that this left significant uncertainty on any mitigation plan and details outstanding with only “illustrative” details included in the Inquiry documents.It was pointed out the original master plan did have some details of planting, the latest updated version as basis for consideration did not, creating less certainty and information about delivery.  Therefore it is argued for making the decision there is less mitigation to be relied on.
  • A debate was then held about the “Canopy” of the site and the 15 years v 25 years assessment.  The vale cited several examples of trees referred to as possible options to plant and cited the difference between the canopy could be 60-75% and so that in their view the mitigation and tree coverage is much less than claimed.It was also again pointed out that the maintenance costs for such a large “open space” to mitigate the damage would fall on only about 130 houses, removing the affordable houses.  So concerns raised not only about the cost (indirectly viability) but that there was also risk of a downgrading of the scheme in reserved matters later.
  • Settlement Gap:  a source of ongoing debate of where the built up boundary of Shrivenham finishes.  The Appellant claims it is at Northford Close, so the golf course is more of a fill in, but the Vale strongly contend it is at Pennyhooks lane, where the new Cross Trees development builds up to. It was pointed out by some residents that  the perception is when you approach Pennyhooks lane you are entering open countryside and so the gap.

The Inspector then asked if any members of the public wanted to ask any questions of the witness.

Cllr Howell explained that the Parish Council had some years ago invested some funds provided from previous developments into some “street art” with the Shrivenham “S” in ironwork on the entry points in the village, aimed at marking the entrance and exit points of the village.  He asked the Appellant if they were aware of the location of these points in respect of the Faringdon road (It is actually just after the pinch point as you exit Shrivenham before Pennyhooks Lane.  There was a discussion then as to whether this could be allowed as new evidence being introduced.  The Inspector allowed it and stated he would view it as part of his next site visit.

The final part of the afternoon session was focused on Trees.  

There were not many areas of significant differences, but some clarification discussions.  In total 241 trees would be lost, mostly Mature trees. It was noted all trees with preservation orders (TPO) would be retained. Some discussion of the way trees have been categorised – A/B/C based on condition/expected life etc.  and that most of the trees are type B.

Friday Day 4 (9:30 start) will be in slightly amended form now, with a session on Environmental Statement and Q&A, some of which already moved to email.  Likely to be a shortened day.

The Inquiry will then resume next Tuesday 29th, with Charlie Maynard MP and a few other public speakers lined up that could not make representations on Day 1. The focus of that day is Golf/Recreation.

Published
September 24, 2026
Last Updated
October 28, 2026
Published in