Procedural/timetable updates at opening focused on expectations of covering materials required before closing the inquiry. Planning matters would be the focus all day, leaving the morning of Thursday free for preparation of closing statements. It is expected these would start at 1pm on Thursday 8th October.
Planning Matters: Mr Jupp representing the Vale walked through his evidence and key points to note.
For Landscape Character the inspector was reminded of some of the previous discussions around some materials provided being illustrative plans only that would be for later finalisation at reserved matters. Concerns were raised about the open space plan and the cost of delivery and maintenance then required via service charges of the homes built. Discussions focused again on the loss of some of the settlement gap and its impact, the loss of trees and the impact on visual separation, particularly from the Faringdon Road, Pennyhooks Lane and the public footpaths.
Golf was re-visited in terms of the National Policy and stressing that the policy statement refers to there being a need to CLEARLY show the site is surplus to golfing needs. It was stated that the existence and availability of other courses did not demonstrate a clear surplus statement.
The alternative open spaces provided that are only illustrative were commented on in that they do not offer suitable replacement overall, particularly in the short term.
Some references were also made to recent Planning Appeals at the “old vet surgery” and the Self build homes, these stated in the decisions that the Inspector noted they (and Northford) were part of the built up area of Shrivenham. This was disputed, and that the key point was there was a clear visual gap that would be lost.
For the healthcare/Community Hub proposal, it was commented that whilst the outline plans only state this is an area of 600sqm, the statement of common ground refers to a 800sqm facility needed. It was also stated that this should not be given much weight due to the funding and deliverability concerns that had already been raised.
The Appellant then cross-examined Mr Jupp with some areas of challenge that the Local plan of the Vale is old, and housing needs out of date. There were also references made to several appeals nationally that were allowed, and questioned the definitions used of unmet need. The above appeals on faringdon road were also referenced where they stated they were in the built up area of Shrivenham, and so this site in not beyond the settlement boundary.
Other areas were debated further – the Golf, open spaces, doctors surgery, trees etc.
After lunch, the Appellant witness would cover planning matters. Unfortunately Cllr Howell could not attend the afternoon.
Proceedings for public attendance are expected to start at 1pm on Thursday when closing statements will be made.