Home News news Planning Inquiry Summary Day 6

Planning Inquiry Summary Day 6

Procedural matters were covered quickly and moved to main content of the day which was focused on Golf matters, principally the assessment of needs and the available supply/provision of Golf in the area.

The first witness was Mr Jupp for the Vale and his evidence walked through the discussion around the Leisure Facilities Assessment Strategy (LFAS) of the Vale.  

In summary, the National policy framework is to protect recreational areas such as a Golf Course unless there is a better alternative provided to replace it, or if there is clearly a surplus of such facilities.  This was the main debate of the day.  The Vale local plan is based on the national policy, and states that development needs should be assessed against the LFAS.  

This LFAS is a district council wide assessment, whereas the Bloor work as a specific site needs assessment.  A lot of discussion during the day focused on “cross border” considerations and the difference between the Vale work as the planning authority, and Bloor’s view that cross border view should be taken. 

The vale team pointed out that without Shrivenham Park Golf Club, the LFAS would be identifying a shortfall in the provision of golf in this part of the Vale.

Cross Examination of Mr Jupp challenged on the validity of the LFAS, and that a wider 30 minute drive view should be considered.  They also challenged on the interpretation of “what assessment” should be done to comply with the National Policy.

On Re-examination, Mr Jupp clarified that clearly residents of Swindon use Shrivenham as a course and vice versa as golfers like to use a variety of courses.

The Inquiry then went on to hear evidence from the Bloor expert witness, Mr Grady, to give evidence focused on the “surplus to requirement” test.

In summary, a lot of data and statistics were presented on participation rates, average memberships etc and the 30 minute drive test.  Courses were quoted including Bassett Down, Broome Manor, Brinkworth and South Cerney. All were quoted as having capacity and within 30 mins.

The Shrivenham Golf finances were then discussed in terms of challenging viability etc and being able to cope with any increases in lease costs from the owners.

Mid-afternoon the cross examination of Mr Grady took place from the Vale team.  They started to re-confirm that as far as Vale Policies are concerned in respect of the Local Plan under which they operate, that they look to the policies and data for the jurisdiction under which they have authority.

Unfortunately Cllr Howell had to leave mid-afternoon, but the cross examination was expected to continue all afternoon.

Day 7 will start at 9:30am and is expected to be focused on Housing Supply data.

Published
September 30, 2026
Last Updated
October 28, 2026
Published in